Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version Share this

By Miriam Raftery

August 19, 2012 – Yesterday the Federal Register included notice that the U.S. Department of Energy has announced it will issue a Presidential permit to Energia Sierra Juarez U.S. Transmission, LLC (ESJ) to construct, operate, maintain and connect a 230 kV electric transmission line across the U.S.-Mexico border in San Diego’s East County. Read the notice:

The Environmental Impact Statement for the project warned that “Potential impacts to habitat and vegetation in the U.S. could result from a wildfire originating in Mexico and spreading across the U.S.-Mexico border…. Wind turbines planned for construction in Mexico as part of the ESJ Wind Project, including associated safety lighting, would be visible from several viewing points in the U.S., resulting in a potential long-term impact to individuals in the U.S.”

San Diego Supervisor Dianne Jacob, who represents East County, opposed the project and was the only Supervisor to vote against its approval. She denounced it as a fire hazard and further has said that reliance on power from a foreign country with an unstable government is not sound energy policy.

The transmission line would originate at San Diego Gas and Electric's planned East County Substation (ECO Substation), and extend southward approximately 0.65 miles to the U.S. border with Mexico, near Jacumba, California, where it would cross the border and connect with a transmission line to be built in Mexico."

The ESJ transmission line project would connect to the planned 1,250 Megawatt (MW) ESJ Wind Project to be located in the general vicinity of La Rumorosa, Northern Baja California, Mexico. Delivery within California of the output of ESJ wind turbines in Mexico would be scheduled by the California Independent System Operator (CAISO).

Bonnie Price, past president of the La Mesa-Foothills Democratic Club, called the Department of Energy’s action “outrageous” and urged party members to “intervene with the President” by informing him of the dangers posed by the lines and asking him to revoke the approval. (The president may be contacted via the White House website at )

Error message

Support community news in the public interest! As nonprofit news, we rely on donations from the public to fund our reporting -- not special interests. Please donate to sustain East County Magazine's local reporting and/or wildfire alerts at to help us keep people safe and informed across our region.


Energia Transmission Line Permit

It is your responsibility a "credible" journalist to report the facts correctly and to not mischaracterize a process that is actually in place to provide for public vetting of government decisions. If you read the Record of Decision by the Energy Department (date 8/18), you will see it says that the government has decided to issue the permit but nowhere does it say that it has already occurred. Under national law, once a government body issues a decision under national environmental review laws, it must wait to actually carry out its decision for 30 days. That means that at the earliest the government could issue the permit in September. This is already a hot topic in this area and such misinformation - whether intended or not - does not service the public or ongoing debate about all of these development project popping up everywhere. Thanks.

Energia Transmission Line Permit

I thought from the wording that this was a done deal. I have changed it accordingly.  The actual Record of Decision concludes as follows:


DOE has determined that the potential impacts from the Route for
the Double-Circuit 230-kV Transmission Line are expected to be small,
as discussed above.
For the reasons stated above, DOE will issue Presidential Permit
PP-334 to authorize ESJ to construct, operate, maintain, and connect
the Energia Sierra Juarez U.S. Double-Circuit 230-kV Transmission Line
across the U.S. border. Presidential Permit PP-334 will limit the
project to a maximum of 400 MW.