Updated May 1, 2017 9:30 p.m. to add statement from Warren Throckmorton calling Barton an "academic fraud" for misleading statements about his own academic record, including a PhD from a "diploma mill" and a claim to have played college basketball that the school could not substantiate. See his full e-mail at the end of this article.
By Miriam Raftery
May 1, 2017 (El Cajon) – Multiple East County leaders are speaking out to voice opposition to David Barton, a debunked “Christian Nation” advocate, speaking May 4th at an East County Mayors Prayer Lunch at the Crystal Palace in El Cajon. Barton has long claimed that the Founding Fathers did not support a separation of church and state. His book, The Jefferson Lies, was pulled off the market by its publisher after conservative Christian scholars exposed many falsehoods.
Barton is listed as an extremist on the Southern Poverty Law Center’s watch list for his virulent anti-gay views. He has also drawn fire for anti-Muslim remarks and some stances views as racist. He has advocated to remove civil rights leader Martin Luther King and farmworkers organizer Cesar Chavez from school text books.
In a recent interview with Christian Broadcasting Network, he urged Christian Evangelicals that they have a Biblical “duty” to vote for candidates who will support anti-abortion judges and who oppose equal rights for LGTBQ individuals. “It’s not your vote. It’s God’s vote,” he stated. On his Wallbuilders Live radio show, he claimed that the same “evil” responsible for the Holocaust is today responsible for the “homosexual lifestyle.”
Just who is behind inviting Barton to speak at a function with local governmental leaders is unclear. But his appearance has prompted a backlash.
The luncheon is being promoted by local churches, conservative political insiders and the East County Chamber, but president Eric Lund told East County Magazine it is not a Chamber event. The RSVP phone number goes to an employee at a local car dealership, who has not returned our call asking who is organizing the event. Several local political insiders have said off-record that an evangelical church is behind the event. Another said a prominent conservative politician is the driving force.
“I’d like to know where the money goes,” Councilman Ben Kalasho told East County Magazine.
Lemon Grove Councilmember Jennifer Mendoza said the event has always been held on the National Day of Prayer. She said Foothills Church has collected money for this year’s event. The church’s website does not list the event.
“I belong to the Lemon Grove Interfaith Association and we bought a table,” she said, adding that she pays her own way. “I’ve gone before and it was just a bunch of East County pastors and the public praying for our cities…Last year, there were Muslim groups in attendance and we have several Hispanic churches sitting at our table.”
She adds, “ I had no idea who the speaker was. Usually it’s a local pastor who speaks.”
Mendoza added, “I cancelled my attendance at this lunch. I can’t support this guy.” She said she advised “in no uncertain terms” her reasons for cancelling, also notifying “my local Lemon Grove contingent to know why I wasn’t attending, as well as our mayor.”
Several years ago, El Cajon resident Ray Lutz, then president of the East County Democratic Club, wrote a letter to El Cajon’s City Attorney that resulted in Wallbuilders’ videos on the history of pastors in America being taken down off El Cajon’s public TV website. Lutz contended that religious videos on a government site violated the U.S. Constitution. The videos covered the history of pastors in America, God in government, and one claimed that African-Americans should vote Republican because Lincoln, a Republican, freed slaves during the Civil War.
Regarding Barton’s appearance at the local mayors’ prayer breakfast, Lutz said, “That sounds like the typical East County violation of separation of church and state that they’ve been doing for years. It’s said to see that David Barton is still around.” He recalled that El Cajon played his videos daily for years until Lutz’s letter. “That’s really what started Citizens Oversight,” he said of the nonprofit he started which has since taken on major battles ranging from voting integrity to San Onofre nuclear easte issues.
Lutz told ECM that he is “very concerned about this as our East County area is largely controlled by the large mega churches.” He added that he expects to write letters voicing concerns and will “probably investigate if any city is playing the fake-history David Barton videos that promote church-state integration and extreme and intolerant values.”
The invitation states, “Your opportunity to join the hands-on collaborative efforts of government, business, and church officials working together to meet the needs of our cities.”
Speakers listed besides Barton include all four East County Mayors: Bill Wells, El Cajon, John Minto, Santee, Racquel Vasquez, Lemon Grove, and Mark Arapostathis, La Mesa, as well as Dr. David Miyashiro of Cajon Valley Union School District.
The webpage for the event describes Barton as “Founder and President of WallBuilders, a national pro-family organization that presents America’s forgotten history and heroes, with an emphasis on our moral, religious and constitutional heritage,” a description with which many critics including historians and conservative religious scholars would differ.
Some of the “history” he presents is, in fact, fiction.
Just how inaccurate and extreme are Barton’s views and writings?
Warren Throckmorton and Michael Coulter, professors at Pennsylvania’s Grove City college, published a detailed refutation of Barton’s book on Jefferson. Both are conservative Christian scholars at an institution that touts the “ethical absolutes of the Ten Commandments and Christ’s moral teachings” among other Christian values.
Yet Throckmorton found Barton’s claims on Jefferson disregarded objective facts. He also found that Barton’s hate speech toward gays has been cited by another extremist claiming the First Amendment doesn’t protect non-Christians and advocating for a Ugandan bill calling for death for homosexuals.
Barton has falsely insisted that our founding fathers “had the entire debate on creation and evolution” and chose creationism. However Charles Darwin didn’t publish his theory of evolution until 1859, over 50 years later. Similarly, he has claimed without substantiation that the Constitution contains Biblical references.
He falsely claimed Jefferson helped fund production of an early Bible printed in America, when in fact Jefferson merely ordered one copy of the Bible to add to his vast collection of books.
He falsely claimed President Ronald Reagan opposed gun control even after he was shot in an attempted assassination. In fact, Reagan wrote an editorial published in the New York Times supporting the Brady gun control bill in Congress.
In opposing having school children learn about Martin Luther King Jr. as an advocate of minority rights, Barton stated that “only majorities can expand political rights.”
He was once named among Time Magazine’s 25 most influential evangelicals in 2005, but has since fallen from grace in the eyes of many religious and political leaders due to his extremist views and lack of credibility.
Journalist Garrett Epps wrote in The Atlantic, “For at least the past 20 years, Barton has been a tireless producer of books and pamphlets designed to demonstrate that America was founded by Christians and should be governed by Christians, that the separation of church and state is a myth, and that Protestant Christianity should be a part of government. In that time, he has come to occupy a position of influence with the Republican Party . (He’s been a consultant to the national Republican Party.)
“ His success is appalling,” Epps concludes, “first because he is not a historian of any kind (his sole degree is from Oral Roberts University in religious education), and second because, even by the standard’s of today’s right wing, he is an obvious crackpot.”
Update: Following publication, we received an email from Throckmorton which reads as follows:
Thanks for your article opposing David Barton's appearance in your community. I appreciate your mention of our book on Jefferson as well.
There is something more that might actually make a difference. Barton recently claimed to have an earned PhD but it came from a diploma mill in FL. He never actually attended the school. Please see these posts:
He also claimed to play Div. 1 basketball for Oral Roberts Univ. which isn't true.
He has engaged in academic fraud but has not yet been held accountable by any Christian organization.