Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version Share this

June 27, 2009 (Washington DC) - The House Armed Services Committee has accepted an amendment offered by Congressman Duncan D. Hunter (R-Alpine) requiring the Secretary of Defense to review the Medal of Honor awards process. Since the start of combat operations in Iraq and Afghanistan, there has not been a single living recipient of the Medal of Honor.

Earlier this year, Congressman Hunter wrote to President Barack Obama regarding the lack of living Medal of Honor recipients and the inconsistent criteria for determining award winners. Hunter specifically raised the circumstances surrounding Marine Corps Sergeant Rafael Peralta, who suppressed a grenade blast with his body and was killed during fighting in Iraq. Sergeant Peralta's Medal of Honor nomination was downgraded to the Navy Cross after a review by an independent panel that consisted of two pathologists and a neurosurgeon.

The response to that letter, written by Undersecretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness Gail McGinn, suggested that electronic warfare may be the reason why only five U.S. troops - all of whom were killed during combat operations in Iraq and Afghanistan -- have been awarded the Medal of Honor. McGinn wrote, "Technological advancements have dramatically changed battlefield tactics, techniques and procedures. Precision-guided, stand-off weapons allow our forces to destroy known enemy positions with reduced personnel risk."

Hunter, a Marine Corps officer who served in the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, responded to that reasoning by saying, "It's true that some aspects of warfare have changed, but what hasn't changed is the close-quarter combat that is required to take ground from the enemy. That is what our Marines and soldiers do. Those actions are no different today than they were at any other time before.” He added, "The lack of Medal of Honor awards in Iraq and Afghanistan suggest that either troops are not as brave as they used to be, which I don't believe is true, or someone has to die in order to receive this honor. And even then, particularly in the case of Sergeant Peralta, the process for determining award winners appears to be inconsistent."

The medal has been awarded to 3,464 men and one woman since it was established into law by President Abraham Lincoln in 1861.

Hunter's amendment directs the Secretary of Defense to review whether acts of valor that traditionally merit the Medal of Honor are being downgraded or award criteria has been subjectively raised to favor actions that only result in death. The Secretary of Defense is then required to report to Congress.

The Fiscal Year 2010 Defense Authorization Act now awaits consideration by the full House.

Error message

Support community news in the public interest! As nonprofit news, we rely on donations from the public to fund our reporting -- not special interests. Please donate to sustain East County Magazine's local reporting and/or wildfire alerts at to help us keep people safe and informed across our region.