Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version Share this
A Jim Bell & Common Sense Commentary
“My vision is to gracefully transform the San Diego/Tijuana Regional economy, now 98% dependent on imported energy and 90% dependent on imported water and food -- into an economy that is prosperous and completely renewable, energy, water and food self-sufficient. Accomplishing this is our best chance to leave our children and future generations a life-support sustaining future. Becoming renewable energy, water and food self-sufficient in our region will also serve as a model that can be emulated around the world.” –Jim Bell.
July 20, 2012 (San Diego) -- We humans are something special and rare.
In spite of there being an estimated 5 million to 100 million species of life on our planet -- our species is the only one that lives and makes a living in ways that hurt our local and global life-support systems.
Yet, even considering all the life-support system damage that human activities have done and are still doing, our species still has the capacity to bring all human activity into life-support harmony.
Ultimately, accomplishing life-support harmony is about consciousness. If enough of us become conscious enough, soon enough, it will be easy to develop jobs and business opportunities that are mutually beneficial and at least life-support system benign. I believe we can do better than benign. I believe that we can develop ways to live and make livings that contribute to human and life-support system health and their renewability.
In other words, the more conscious we become, the better the chance we will be able to pass the birthright of a peaceful and life-support sustaining world to our descendents.
Increasing consciousness will also open us to new potentials and possibilities on this planet and beyond.
Unfortunately, our pursuit of consciousness will be cut short if we continue to live and make livings in ways that hurt others and cause life-support system harm. The aftermath of the Gulf oil gusher and the ongoing radioactive rain from Fukushima Japan’s failed nuclear plant complex -- are two recent examples of how economic gambling can hurt people and our common life-support system far beyond what the gamblers personally risk.
Added to this, the world’s human population continues to grow as does the average amount of life-support damage we cause per capita. If this continues, sooner or later, our planet’s life-support system will fail in some fundamental way. This will result in a human and life in general dieback. If serious enough, human extinction and even the extinction of life in general becomes possible.
Some people believe that such a failure has already begun. They offer as evidence that:
+ As of mid 2012, an estimated 15% or 1/6 of the world’s population (over one billion people) are malnourished or starving and that 70% of us (4.9 billion people) are unemployed or under-employed, have zero or next to zero health care, and are poorly nourished, clothed and housed.
+ Human activities are causing the extinction of an estimated 27,000 species of life each year. This rate is 100 to 1,000 times greater than the historic or normal rate of extinction over the 3.5 billion years there is fossil evidence for life existing. The current extinction rate is comparable to the rate of extinction 65 million years ago when the age of the dinosaurs came to an end. There are a number of theories as to the cause of the accelerated rate of extinctions 65 million years ago, but a consensus of extinction event scientists are leaning toward it being caused by the collision with an asteroid, perhaps 10 kilometers in diameter, that struck the Yucatan Peninsula 65 million years ago. The contemporary rate of species extinctions is caused primarily by past and ongoing human assaults on each other and on our planet’s life-support system. It seems that the human family has become its own asteroid.
There’s a belief that early humans were more conscious about nature and were more protective of the natural world of life than people today. Some peoples did understand this and lived and made livings in ways that made them prosperous and life-support sustaining. Unfortunately, most human activities have been life-support system damaging. This has been true for most of human history, but before the industrial revolution, human numbers were still relatively small as was the life-support damage per capita. Because of this, human caused life-support damage of the past could usually be healed by nature given enough time.
But with the industrial revolution, fuel was plentiful and its cost was low. With cheap energy to run powerful machines like bulldozers, the human family’s average negative impact on the beauty, majesty and productive potential of our planet’s life-support system has and is still growing exponentially.
Next came the chemical revolution. The soldiers in this ongoing revolution are chemists. Mostly over the last 80 years, chemists have created an estimated 80,000 to 150,000 chemicals. Many of them have been and are continuing to be released planet wide. As our knowledge grows, we see increasing evidence that the long term impact of such practices goes on and on in our food chain, in the water we drink, and the food we eat.
Additionally, many of these chemicals have never existed on our planet before human chemists invented them. The result is that our bodies and our planet’s life-support system are awash with chemicals that our bodies and life-support system have had zero experience in responding to or processing. We and our life-support system can be negatively affected by chemicals naturally found on earth when they are manufactured in vast amounts, then released into our common air, water and food. We are adding an estimated 1,000 new chemicals to our planet’s life-support system each year.
Now we are in the mist of the biological, biochemical and electronic revolutions and these new revolutions are turning out to be just as damaging and possibility more damaging to human and life-support system health than the revolutions discussed earlier.  
Unfortunately, there are numerous additional negatives beyond what has been pointed out above. But even with all this given, the bottom line question for those who love their children and grandchildren and the beauty, majesty and sustainable productive potential of our planet’s life-support system is: What should we do to give our children and future generations their best chance to live in a prosperous, peaceful and life-support sustaining future?
On the most fundamental level, answering this question comes down to consciousness. If each of us and the human family as a whole, become conscious enough, it will be easy to resolve human differences without violence or its threat and develop economies and ways of life that are beneficial to everyone and are completely life-support sustaining.
It’s true that some people have done and are doing despicable things to other people and to our common life-support system, but on the whole, we are becoming more conscious. The expansion of women’s rights, the general rejection of racism and the fact that governments no longer sanction slavery -- are just a few examples of our increasing consciousness and empathy.
Never-the-less, we are not yet conscious enough to stop hurting and killing each other and damaging the only life-support system our planet has.
It’s my belief, that if we really want to leave our children and future generations their best chance to enjoy a happy, healthy, prosperous and completely life-support sustaining future, we have to be conscious enough and knowledgeable enough to develop ways to live and make livings that are mutually beneficial and life-support sustaining, wherever we live and planet wide.
If we don’t achieve a life-support sustaining future soon, we will follow the path worn by previous advanced civilizations, all of which utterly failed at the height of their most advanced knowledge and sophistication.
YET, if we become conscious and knowledgeable enough, soon enough -- we can skip the decline and die off phase of past civilizations. Instead, we can propel ourselves to the next level of consciousness and the new potentials it will open to us and to the human family’s future.
Obviously, our task is to meet this challenge, but how?
The answer is simple. We need to develop economies and ways of life that are prosperous, mutually beneficial, secure and life-support sustaining -- wherever people live and ultimately planet wide.
Here are the details of how this can be accomplished:
Step One - Become renewable energy self-sufficient.
When a home, community, city, county, region, state or country controls its energy supply and price, it controls its economy, its ways of life, and almost everything else -- no matter what happens to the price and supply of energy on national and global markets.
Because solar energy in its various forms is free and even delivered free, the only cost to benefit from it are the labor and materials required to increase energy use efficiency and manufacture and install renewable energy collection and conversion to electricity devices.
Given that our inventors/developers are still getting better at saving energy and converting various forms of solar energy into electricity, the cost of efficiency improvements and renewably generated electricity will continue to fall.
To make renewable gaseous and liquid fuels, renewably generated electricity can be used to gasify (heat up in a closed low oxygen chamber) clean wood wastes, urban landscape trimmings, and thinned chaparral (in the San Diego/Tijuana Region where I live). In the gasification or pyrolysis process, liquid fuels in the woody feed-stock are driven off by heat and then converted into renewable oil, liquid and gaseous fuels, charcoal, and soil amendments.
Thinning chaparral will also reduce the occurrence and severity of wildfires and the economic and habitat loss they precipitate.
Every level of becoming renewable energy self-sufficient creates opportunities.
For example, in the San Diego/Tijuana Region where I live, there is an abundance of direct sunlight, wind, biomass, ocean current, wave and tidal energy from which electricity can be produced.
But even if direct sunlight was the region’s only resource, and assuming 40 kWh of electricity, natural gas and transportation fuels are consumed directly or indirectly per capita per day, the San Diego/Tijuana region could become renewable energy self-sufficient by increasing energy use efficiency by 40% across all energy use sectors and by covering 32.3% of its roofs and parking lots (shaded parking) with 20% efficient PV panels.
As a bonus, a renewable energy powered San Diego/Tijuana Region, would convert the region’s current $6 billion-negative-energy-purchase-cash-flow into a $6 billion-positive-energy-purchase-cash-flow. Assuming an economic multiplier benefit for every dollar spent on locally generated energy, at least one additional dollar of regional economic activity will be generated. This means that becoming renewable energy self-sufficient will add at least $12 billion of economic activity to the region’s economy each year.
Assuming that 40% (could be as high as 57%) of the $12 billion spent locally is paid to workers, 40% times $12 billion equals $4.8 billion in wages. Dividing $4.8 billion by $50,000 per job-year of employment equals the generation of 96,000 job-years of employment per year paying an average of $50,000 per job-year of employment.
Step Two - Become renewable water self-sufficient.
Water is essential to life. It is essential to the water-rich lifestyle most people in the developed world already have and that people in the developing world would like to have.
For calculating ease, the following calculations assume that:
+ The population of the Greater Tijuana part of the region is more or less the same as the population of San Diego County.
+ Everyone in the Tijuana part of the region would like to use the same amount of water as is used per capita in San Diego County, around 180 gallons per capita per day..
Given the assumptions above and also assuming the worst case scenario of zero rainfall and zero imported water, how can the San Diego/Tijuana Region become freshwater self-sufficient?
As it turns out, covering 3.75% of the roofs and parking lots (shaded parking) on both sides of the San Diego/Tijuana region with 20% efficient PV panels will generate enough electricity to extract 776,000 acre ft. of freshwater from sand filtered seawater through reverse osmosis (RO) on each side of the border per year.
For reference, the San Diego County side of the region currently uses around 600,000 acre ft. of fresh water per year.
If all cost-effective and life-support-system-effective ways to use water more efficiently, use graywater and disinfected recycled sewage water for irrigation, and rainwater runoff is collected and stored for use during the region’s dry months, only 1.5% if the roofs and parking lots on either side of the border would be need to have 20% PV panels over them, to make the whole region completely renewable water self-sufficient. 
To protect sea life from the RO process, naturally sand filtered seawater will be extracted from wells close to the ocean. Wastewater or brine left over from the RO process will be evaporated in shallow open ponds so salt and other minerals left behind can be mined. When any RO wastewater is returned to the sea, it would be diluted by sand-filtered seawater to be no more than 20% saltier than natural seawater. Then It would be released into the ocean diffusely.
Step Three – Become renewable food self-sufficient.
With renewable energy and water self-sufficiency, comes the ability to be renewable food self-sufficient. It also allows for the growth of a great deal of the fiber and lumber.
To make this real, it is essential that we protect our agricultural soils from further development and other misuse. Research indicates that we still have enough agricultural soil on our planet to feed everyone a nutritious diet of tasty, sustainably-grown food with lots of variety. With renewable energy powered RO, this is true for the San Diego/Tijuana region. Unfortunately, this will not be true for San Diego County or our world for long if we do not protect and preserve our best agricultural soils for life-support sustaining agriculture.
Step Four – Population Reduction
The only just way to reduce population is for:
+ Women to be completely free to direct their own lives as long as they don’t restrict the right of others to do the same.
+ Every man becomes an ally to ensure that women have every freedom to direct their own lives, culturally, under law and to pursue fulfillment in any field open to the human family.
+ The world’s women freely chose to have an average of no more than two birth children per mother during their life. Since some women would choose to bare no children and others only one, some woman could bear three or more children as long as average birth of children per woman remained no more than two children planet wide. 
If the above was practiced worldwide, the world’s population would decline by ½% per year or for every 1,000 deaths, there would 995 births. A ½% per year world population decline would reduce the world’s population to 2.5 billion people in 200 years. This was the world’s population around 1955.
Step Five – Develop a Space Debris Detection and Defense System
We already have the technology to locate all earth-orbit-crossing space objects. If we discover them soon enough, we also have the technology, to deflect earth bound objects large enough to cause serious life-support harm if they collide with us. We could even capture such objects into earth or moon orbits for scientific study and mining.
Step Six – Create a Real Free-Market Economy by Adopting “True-Cost” or “Cradle to Cradle-Pricing”.
Today, almost everything humans do causes life-support system harm. More precisely, it’s not so much about what we are doing, but about HOW we are doing it. The ways we support ourselves now depend on using up ever more non-renewable resources and using renewal resources in ways that make them difficult to renew. The result is over flowing landfills and evermore destruction of virgin land for raw materials to replace those we bury.
With true-cost pricing and cradle to cradle pricing, the true-cost all products and services offered in the marketplace would be determined by an independent body. Perhaps Consumer Reports Magazine which doesn’t advertise products or services could be hired for the job.
The primary job of this body would be to add up the costs of healing people and cleaning up our planet’s life-support system from ongoing human health and life-support system assaults. Once these costs are determined, they would be added to the retail price of products and services that directly or indirectly cause them.
Currently, the public, through taxes, health costs, property damage, etc. pay these costs. By paying them, the public is caught in the ironic position of actually subsidizing the very products and processes that are harming them and their common life-support system.
Additionally, these subsidies retard the development of technologies that are more health and ecologically benign or even positive -- by artificially lowering the retail cost of ecological, health and socially damaging products and services. With true-cost and cradle to cradle pricing, products and services with the lowest true or cradle to cradle cost would also have the lowest retail market price.
As technologies become more ecologically sophisticated there is no reason for commonly used products to be any more expensive to purchase than they are now. In fact, in spite of the subsidies supporting health and life-support damaging products, the market price of some “Green” products is already lower than harmful products they replace and they usually work better too.
But even if green products and technologies end up costing more at the point of purchase, under true-cost-pricing they would still be more cost effective to society. It's less expensive to prevent ecological and social problems, than to fix them after they have been created.
Additional true-cost-cradle to cradle pricing benefits includes:
+ Incentivizing designers and manufacturers to create products and services that are in harmony with human and our planet’s life-support system’s health.
+ The elimination of solid waste disposal. With true-cost-pricing or cradle to cradle pricing, everything sold in the marketplace would be designed to be reused, recycled or composted. When all costs are included, this is the most cost effective thing to do.
+ The elimination of the pollution of air, water and food.
There is a general view that the free enterprise system is the antithesis of a healthy environment. With true-cost-pricing or cradle to cradle pricing, free market forces will be powerful tools toward creating a more secure life-support sustaining future.
Final Thoughts:
Bottom line, if we want to leave the birthright of a happy, healthy, prosperous, life-supporting sustainable future to our children and future generations, these 5 steps are the minimum we must do, and the sooner the better.
We’ve come so far, why blow it now? We know what can be done. All we have to do is do it. If those living over the next 60 years or so develop life-support sustaining economies and ways of life planet wide, there is little to stop us from accomplishing anything we can imagine including sustainably colonizing other planets  in our own galaxy and beyond in life-support sustainable ways suited to .
For details on an investment strategy to make the San Diego County side of the region renewable energy, water and food self-sufficient, go to and click on “Green Papers”. Although this paper focuses on San Diego County becoming renewableelectricity self-sufficient, the investment strategies it develops can be used to become renewable energy self-sufficient for gaseous and liquid fuels as well. This strategy can work almost anywhere on our planet, modified for climate, renewable energy sources available and other local conditions. With additional modifications, it will also work for becoming renewable water and food self-sufficient as well.

The views expressed in this editorial reflect the views of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of East County Magazine. To submit an editorial for consideration, contact


Error message

Local news in the public interest is more important now than ever, during the COVID-19 crisis. Our reporters, as essential workers, are dedicated to keeping you informed, even though we’ve had to cancel fundraising events. Please give the gift of community journalism by donating at