Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version Share this

By Laurie Baker

December 4, 2012 (McCain Valley) -- This is a warning for those who escape to Cottonwood Campground in McCain Valley for a tranquil and refreshing experience to explore the Great Outdoors:  Your days of enjoyment are numbered.   Wind turbines will soon be invading the area just like the ones in Ocotillo.   The Sunrise Powerlink already obliterates the natural beauty along parts of the 13-mile dirt road to the remote campground.    Building 450-foot tall wind turbines a little more than 1,000 feet away from it will completely destroy its appeal altogether.  

McCain Valley, and the adjacent Wilderness Areas, are described in one hiking book as, "Some of the most wild, beautiful and serene territory in San Diego County".   Therefore, demolishing its attractive natural resources seems unthinkable.  However, the lack of attention which is already evident at the campground, on hiking trails, and on open countryside at this far end of the valley explains why it is possible.   Sometimes there are no envelopes available to pay camping fees.   The bathrooms run out of toilet paper.   The trashcans are overflowing and trash bags left sitting on the ground next to them waiting to be collected attract wild animals, such as coyotes, that rip them apart.   Many of the trail signs directing hikers to designated destinations are unreadable and have been that way for years.   Sombrero Peak no longer has a hiker's register box at the summit to share and record hiking experiences.   Tire tracks and crushed cactus on open countryside are encountered while hiking, even in State Park lands.   "Booties" and garbage from illegals litter the stream near the spring in Pepperwood Canyon.   Adjacent Wilderness Areas are left vulnerable.

A call to the Bureau of Land Management shed some light on this disgraceful situation.   One ranger left, and the vacant position was just recently filled.   Staffing is stretched thin for the amount of area that needs to be maintained.   Budget constraints force having to set priorities for those needs accordingly.   Cottonwood Campground must be near the bottom of the list.

Despite it all, the namesake cottonwood trees are lovely to gaze at as their golden leaves shimmer in the autumn breeze.   The songbirds are fun to watch and pleasant to hear.   Unseen owls eerily hoot back and forth to one another at night from the oak trees reminding you that they are there, hidden in the darkness.   The Milky Way reveals itself in the dark sky.   Gorgeous sunrises and sunsets illuminate unspoiled landscapes and skies with vivid colors.  Mountain peaks and ridges that rim the valley rise far above the desert floor offering scenic vistas in all directions, some for a hundred miles or more.   Large boulders are wind-sculpted into interesting and whimsical shapes and provide shelter from the sun or inclement weather.   Raptors, including Golden Eagles, soar high above ridgetops on winds with outstretched wings.   Relics of Native Americans and early settlers are discovered here and there.  Cooling waters and palm groves in remote wilderness canyons below offer respite in an arid environment.  


By the way, have you noticed the sign on McCain Valley Road recently?   It is a sad sign of the times.  It proclaims that McCain Valley is no longer a Conservation Area, but is now a Recreation Area.   Considering the neglect Cottonwood Campground and the surrounding areas display right now, you would think it's been forgotten instead of being portrayed as one of the main draws on the website.   Wind turbines must have some unknown recreational value or they wouldn't be in a Recreation Area, right?   Whatever designation it is given, McCain Valley will endure.   However,  it will be FOREVER changed by the onslaught of industrialization, and it is all so very sad to witness!

The views in this editorial reflect the views of its author and do not necessarily reflect the views of East County Magazine. To submit an editorial for consideration, contact


Error message

Support community news in the public interest! As nonprofit news, we rely on donations from the public to fund our reporting -- not special interests. Please donate to sustain East County Magazine's local reporting and/or wildfire alerts at to help us keep people safe and informed across our region.


Regional name changes are needed

Around the country it is common to rename streets or locations after a death or to memorialize tragic events.  This should also take place in the region of the McCain Valley. A tragedy has unfolded and this area will be forever contaminated by these turbines. Since everyone realizes how this project was approved and permitted, I think the McCain Valley should be renamed "Corruption Valley."    Tule Peak should also be renamed Dead Eagle Mountain.  If there is a vista point overlooking Corruption Valley,  it should be named after Governor Brown.  In fact all the locations around this environmental disaster should be appropriately renamed because what happened here should  be remembered for generations.


Hi Laurie, 

 I share your frustration about the conditions at McCain and other parks and campgrounds that aren't maintained. I went to Lark Canyon camp a few years ago and the place was trashed. On another visit 30 teens were having a keg party.  

The BLM  doesn't get the big money that the Border Patrol does, so there are  very few Rangers to cover a large area. I talked to a Ranger who I met at Superstition in the desert  at Lark Canyon and he told me about the long days and nights, he works solo and back-up can be hours away. He works out of the El Centro office.   Another Ranger I met lives in Julian and is allowed to take his BLM truck home so he can respond to emergencies. They don't do the maintaince, who does?

Will I still goto McCain? yeah. Will it ever be the same?


Much of our backcountry is

Much of our backcountry is about to be destroyed. And where are the greens; the Sierra Club, Greenpeace et al.? Silent, and nowhere to be seen. One thing's for sure: With landscape goes their credibility as champions and spokesmen for the wilderness. Could anything be more contrary to the principles and passions of John Muir? Of course not. They are a disgrace.